GOP Points To Cap-And-Trade Documents
Amy Harder
Wednesday, September 16, 2009 4:50 PM
GOP lawmakers are citing recently released Treasury Department documents to purport that the administration has "privately concluded" a cap-and-trade law would cost American households $1,700 a year, a claim that Democratic strategists and environmental groups are calling bunk.
Democrats maintain that reports from the Congressional Budget Office and Environmental Protection Agency have estimated a cap-and-trade system would cost households between $110 and $170 a year.
The Republicans' assertion, based on a blog post written Tuesday night by conservative CBS columnist Declan McCullagh, started circulating in e-mails today from the National Republican Congressional Committee and the offices of House Republican Conference Chairman Mike Pence of Indiana and Senate Environment and Public Works ranking member James Inhofe of Oklahoma.
"Republicans are trying to scare people away from the energy bill," said Tony Kreindler, media director for the Environmental Defense Fund's climate change division. "They lost on the science argument a long time ago, so they've moved on to economics."
NRCC spokesman Paul Lindsay argued that the economic costs of a cap-and-trade system amount to a "job-killing National Energy Tax." Lindsay also referenced a report by the conservative Heritage Foundation estimating that costs to households would be $1,900, similar to what McCullagh suggested in his post.
Advertisement
Advertisement
Energy Experts Blog
Our panel of insiders discusses key issues
- What's A Winning Strategy For Renewables?
- Budget Crunching: What Happens Now?
- Can Obama Re-energize Climate?
Resources
Guide to researching the energy & climate change debate
Energy Promise Audit
Tracking Obama's progress on campaign promises
- Help U.S. Automakers Adapt
Updated: February 09, 2010 - Help Manufacturers Go Green
Updated: February 09, 2010 - Reduce Electricity Demand 15 Percent In 10 Years
Updated: February 09, 2010
Copenhagen Insider
Visit Copenhagen Insider for National Journal's coverage of the recent U.N. summit including reporting from Darren Goode and analysis from stakeholders in the climate change discussion.
